Saturday, February 28, 2015

18th Century Understanding of Ephesians 5:19

John Gill is a revered but now underused Baptist theologian and Bible commentator who died in 1771. He's famous for his comments on the Old Testament, being an outstanding Hebrew scholar and an expert in ancient Jewish historical writings and commentaries.

Reading through the histories of the kings of Israel and Judah, and the exile and subsequent return of Judah into their land, I've now arrived near the end of these accounts to the book of Nehemiah, which describes how the public worship prescribed by God through David is reestablished. Gill observes that "there was song at the time of the daily sacrifice, in which prayer was also made, as in many of the songs, hymns, and psalms of David..." 

In using the phrase "songs, hymns, and psalms of David," Gill showed that he, like other Puritan and Reformed theologians, understood Paul's "psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs" in Ephesians 5:19 and Colossians 3:16 to refer (only) to the book of Psalms in the Old Testament. But this understanding came under increasing attack from the mid-1700's onward, to the point that people now believe that the Greek hymnos in the New Testament refers to uninspired songs composed by men. It's good to read older theologians and their comments on Scripture so we can see that we aren't the first people to study the Bible and reach conclusions on the meaning of Scripture.

Sunday, February 22, 2015

Working Hard To Deny The Obvious


Many have worked hard to make Paul's "psalms, hymns and spiritual songs" (Ephesians 5:19 and Colossians 3:16) to mean "songs in addition to" the inspired Psalms. Here's an example of this I recently came across. The first few paragraphs reveal the good-intentioned, I am sure, author's dilemma:

"Christian Hymns of the First Three Centuries"
There is no part of the general field of Christian hymnology so baffling to the student or so full of difficulties as the one under consideration in this paper [i.e., the non-Psalm hymnody of the early church]... This is due, first of all, to the unexpected scarcity of original sources. When one views the rise of Christianity from its inception to the period of the Council of Nicaea, 325, its numerical growth from a handful of original adherents to millions of followers at the time of the Edict of Milan, 313, its literary development from early scattered records to the works of the great Greek and Latin fathers, one cannot help inquiring, “What has become of their hymns?”

No wonder finding information on the supposed hymnody sung by millions in the first three centuries of the early church proves baffling and full of difficulties!  This difficulty in finding hymn texts is due to "the unexpected scarcity of original sources." In other words, when researchers go looking for the supposed non-Psalm hymns of the early church they come up empty-handed, and this doesn't make sense to them, considering the otherwise tremendous body of writings that has come down to us from that period. This leads researchers to scratch their heads and wonder, "What has become of their hymns?" The article continues:

Let us abandon at once our contemporary connotation of the word 'hymn'...In the pre-Ambrosian period, Christian hymns were largely of the psalm type, to be chanted in rhythmic periods without rhyme. Not only should the word hymn be conceived in terms of ancient thought, but also the futile attempt to differentiate among psalms, hymns and canticles should be avoided. (Italics and quotes mine)
The researcher admits freely that our contemporary understanding of the word 'hymn' is unhelpful in determining what the early church sang, as their hymns were "largely of the Psalm type." In fact, of course, they were the Psalms, and the article all but admits it when it says that the "futile attempt to differentiate among psalms, hymns and canticles [again, Ephesians 5:19 and Colossians 3:16] should be avoided." The author continues:

Specialists in liturgical matters testify to the confusion existing among ancient writers in the use of these words and to the uncertainty of definition which results.

Surely this isn't in reference to Paul when the writer speaks of the "confusion existing among ancient writers?" The apostle was not confused about what the church was to sing or confused in his choice of words. Neither was the ancient church confused about what to sing, or confused about Paul's choice of words. Paul's "psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs" were all nouns from the Greek Old Testament in use by the church in that day, and were commonly understood to be terms that described the Old Testament Psalms.
It is better not to multiply difficulties but to hold fast to the actual texts which we know were used in Christian worship. In this study, the extant hymnic sources will be presented objectively. Groups of hymns will be used to illustrate the types current in the period. 
The article speaks confidently of "actual texts which we know were used in Christian worship," of "extant hymn sources," and of "groups of hymns used to illustrate the types current in the period." But then what follows is an attempt to force various early documents, including some New Testament passages, to yield hymn texts,*  but this is all based purely on conjecture, and is anything but objective, solid reporting. The fact is that the only texts that are known to have been used in Christian worship were the Psalms. There is no record that uninspired songs were used in the public worship of the church in its first centuries.

*********************************************************************************


It makes one wonder! Why the ongoing, relentless effort to deny the fact that the early church sang the Psalms exclusively (just as the Old Testament church had done)?

*On the supposed hymn fragments contained in the NT epistles, see here.



Wednesday, February 18, 2015

And More On Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs

G.I. Williamson on what Paul meant by the phrase (in Ephesians 5 and Colossians 3) "psalms, hymns and spiritual songs:"

The proper interpretation of scripture terms requires that we discover, not what we mean by these terms when we use them today, but what the inspired writer meant when he used them. And it is one of the oddities of biblical interpretation that this rule is commonly observed with reference to the term 'psalms', and commonly disregarded with respect to the terms 'hymns' and 'songs'. For the fact is that all three of these terms are used in the Bible to designate various selections contained in the Old Testament Psalter. 

In the Greek version of the Old Testament familiar to the Ephesians and Colossians the entire Psalter is entitled 'Psalms'. In sixty-seven of the titles within the book the word 'psalm' is used. However, in six titles the word 'hymn' is used, rather than 'psalm', and in thirty-five the word 'song' appears. Even more important, twelve titles use both 'psalm' and 'song', and two have 'psalm' and 'hymn'. Psalm seventy-six is designated 'psalm, hymn and song'. And at the end of the first seventy two psalms we read that 'the hymns of David the son of Jesse are ended' (Ps. 72:20.) In other words, there is no more reason to think that the Apostle referred to psalms when he said 'psalms' than when he said 'hymns' and 'songs', for the simple reason that all three were biblical terms for psalms in the book of psalms itself. 

We are in the habit of using the terms 'hymns' and 'songs' for those compositions that are not psalms. But Paul and the Christians at Ephesus and Colossae used these terms as the Bible itself uses them, namely, as titles for the various psalms in the Old Testament Psalter. To us it may seem strange, or even unnecessary, that the Holy Spirit would use a variety of titles to describe His inspired compositions. But the fact is that He did so. Just as the Holy Spirit speaks of His 'commandments and his statutes and his judgments' (Deut.. 30:16, etc.), and of 'miracles and wonders and signs' (Acts 2:22), so He speaks of His 'psalms, hymns and songs'. As commandments, statutes and judgments are all divine laws in the language of scripture; as miracles and wonders and signs are all supernatural works of God in the language of scripture; so psalms, hymns and songs are the inspired compositions of the Psalter, in the language of scripture itself... 

The New Testament evidence sustains this conclusion. On the night of the Last Supper Jesus and His disciples sang 'a hymn' (Matt. 26:30). Bible expositors admit that this was the second part of the Hallel Psalms (115-118), which were always sung at the Passover. (New Bible Commentary, p. 835.) Matthew called this psalm a 'hymn' because a psalm is a hymn in the terminology of the Bible. To the same effect is the Old Testament quotation in Hebrews 2:12, in which the Greek word 'hymn' is quoted from Psalm 22:22. In this quotation from an Old Testament psalm, the word 'hymn' is used to denote the singing of psalms because the Old Testament makes no distinction between the two. But if Scripture itself says that psalms are hymns, and that hymns are psalms, why should we make any distinction between them?

If we grant that the Apostle used biblical language in a biblical sense there is no more reason to think that he spoke of uninspired hymns in these texts (Col. 3:16, Eph. 5:19) than to think that he spoke of uninspired psalms, because hymns are inspired psalms in the holy scriptures.

Saturday, February 7, 2015

On Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs

I have posted a link to this before but will do so again today because it's just that helpful. R. Scott Clark discusses what Paul means by telling the church to sing "psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs." What did those terms mean to Paul's readers: did they mean the same to them as they do to us today? Very necessary information in framing the conversation about what we are to sing in public worship.

Psalms, Hymns, and Spiritual Songs in the Septuagint

Friday, December 5, 2014

I Don't Want To Sing Psalms, I Want To Sing About Christ!

"Martin Luther used to call the Book of Psalms "a little Bible." Bishop Horne describes it as "an epitome of the Bible." These terms are fully justified in the fact that in the Psalter we find concentrated all the truths which are elsewhere elaborated and enforced in all the divine Word. It thus possesses an internal completeness not found in any other single book in the inspired volume. Having, evidently, this thought in mind, Thomas Scott, the eminent commentator, says, "There is nothing in true religion -- doctrinal, experimental, and practical -- but will present itself to our attention whilst we meditate upon the Psalms. The Christian's use of them in the closet, and the minister's in the pulpit, will generally increase with the growing experience of the power of true religion in their own hearts."

"One essential reason for this internal completeness of the Psalter is that Christ is the central figure in it, as He is in the entire Word of God. Every book, indeed, of the Old Testament is intended to lead directly or indirectly to Jesus Christ. But in this respect the Book of Psalms stands preeminent among the entire thirty-nine." 

Read the entire article here. 

Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Making Melody in the New Testament

“Either Way, We Must Sing and Sing Only”
David B. Smith

"Psallo is one of five plural participles in Ephesians 5:19-21, used to explain how a person is to be “filled with the Spirit” [or as it is paralleled in Col. 3:16, to “let the word dwell in one richly”]. The five participles are speaking, singing, making melody, giving thanks and submitting. In Ephesians 5:19, psallo is translated “making melody.” Unfortunately, some people abuse the term in an effort to justify the use of instrumental music in worship. In fact some corrupted versions of the Bible completely disregard the meaning of the term, like the Amplified Bible which reads “offering praise with voices [and instruments]...” Such abuses go far in showing the lack of regard many translators have for the inspiration of the Bible. 

"Psallo (Greek) is the New Testament equivalent to the Old Testament zamar (Hebrew). But even in the Old Testament, the word zamar did not inherently mean “to use the instrument.” The context determined whether the instrument was included. It is only used figuratively in the New Testament. And all credible translators know that it is only correct to translate the term into something like “making melody.” Lexicographers agree on this point. The object of the verb would decide whether the instrument was intended. And in Ephesians 5:19, there are only two options – neither of which authorizes natural or mechanical instruments of music: 

"1. If the phrase is taken locatively, it means that making melody occurs “in the heart.” In such a case, melody is restricted to this one location, since 'specific action commands' exclude all other actions.

"2. If the phrase is taken in the instrumental case, it means that making melody occurs “with the heart.” In such a case, the heart is the only tool God allows for the making of the melody.

"Herein is the beauty of the phrase, as it appears in the Bible: the meaning is the same regardless. Either way, the songs must be sung and the melody must be made in the heart of man and with the heart of man. To use a play on words, the heart is the only authorized instrument. There can be no other conclusion but this.

"So when saints come together and blend their voices in song, they can be confident that they are accomplishing exactly what God requires for this act of worship without addition or subtraction. And this is the key to true worship (John 4:23-24), which goes before God as a sweet smelling savor."

https://www.thelordsway.com/SODDYDAISYTN/doclib/psallo.pdf

Thursday, September 18, 2014

The Keliy of the Old Testament, The Hoplon of the New


It's interesting to consider the use of the term "musical instrument" in Scripture. Our present usage of the phrase could possibly skew our understanding of the place and sanction of musical instruments in worship, particularly in the Levitical sacrificial system as compared to now.

In the Bible, the Hebrew word keliy is often translated by the word "instrument."  But it's also variously translated "furniture," "articles," "weapons," "clothing," "baggage," armor," "yoke," "tool," "implement," "jar," "vessel," and "equipment." Strong's defines keliy as "an article, a vessel, an implement, a utensil, a tool." The various keliy were often those things which had a common use; but sometimes keliy is used to describe things set apart to a holy use. For instance, in Exodus 25:9, keliy describes the various furnishings of the Tabernacle. God tells Moses, "According to all that I shew thee, after the pattern of the tabernacle, and the pattern of all the instruments (keliy) thereof, even so shall ye make it." These instruments included the ark, the mercy seat, the cherubim, the table, and the candlestick. Keliy in the Old Testament was something useful, something that furnished out, equipped. When used in worship, these articles and implements were strictly regulated by God, to be made and used according to God's exact pattern.

In due course of time, God gave an expanded pattern of worship to David, along with the prophets Nathan and Gad, with exact instructions for additional keliy for use in the Temple in the worship of God. These were also strictly regulated by God, and would be implements for the sounding of music. 1 Chronicles 15:16: "And David spake to the chief of the Levites to appoint their brethren [to be] the singers with instruments (keliy) of musick, psalteries and harps and cymbals, sounding, by lifting up the voice with joy." 

So, in the Old Testament, there were keliy for the Tabernacle, keliy for warfare, keliy for farming, keliy for food and eating, keliy for clothing the body, and then, beginning in 1 Chronicles 15:16 with David's appointment of the Levites, keliy for music. All keliy for worship were strictly appointed and regulated by God, whether the candlesticks for the tabernacle or later for the loud-sounding cymbals for the temple. 2 Chronicles 29:25: "And he set the Levites in the house of the LORD with cymbals, with psalteries, and with harps, according to the commandment of David, and of Gad the king's seer, and Nathan the prophet: for so was the commandment of the LORD by his prophets."


In the New Testament, the only Greek word that conveys the same sense as keliy is hoplon, which appears once, in Romans 6:13: "Do not present your members to sin as instruments (hoplon). Strong's defines hoplon as "any tool or implement...arms used in warfare, weapons." So hoplon in the New Testament also conveys the idea of a utensil, a tool, something used; even for warfare, as does keliy in some places in the Old.

Now a little about the use of the English word "instrument" to translate keliy. It was surely chosen carefully by the early translators of the English Bible, because at that time, it still conveyed the sense of its roots, which were in the Old French estrument and the Latin instrumentem; its definition was "a tool, apparatus, furniture, dress, document." Instrumentem is from instruere (to instruct, to arrange, to inform, to teach).  We still retain a vestige of this earlier meaning when we speak of surgical instruments, and also, in keeping with the idea of instruction, of legal instruments.

Mostly, we now associate the word instrument with music. But the earlier translators chose the word instrument to translate various instances of the Hebrew keliy because, for them, it still had connotations of being something useful, a tool or an implement; and because of its associations with the ideas of furnishing out and instructing, as the musical instruments were to do for that age of the church.

Hopefully all this helps to show that the musical keliy of  David and the Temple were divinely appointed implements that furnished out the public worship of God for that time, just as the earlier keliy had furnished out public worship in the Tabernacle. Most know and agree that the keliy of the Tabernacle served as mere copies of the heavenly realities they represented. When the heavenly reality came, and was fulfilled in the Person and work of the Lord Jesus Christ, so did the need for, and usefulness of, these copies. They were ceremonial, and vanished away. And this is just as true for all the later keliy of the Temple, including its musical keliy. They were commanded for use by the Levites for raising sounds of joy (1 Chronicles 15:16-28) and for giving thanks (2 Chronicles 7:6). The musical keliy were themselves the sound of praise. They served as types and shadows of what was to come at the inauguration of the new and better covenant—  sacrifices of praise and thanks to God from hearts "richly indwelt by the word of Christ;" praises voiced without elaborate ceremony by "singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord" (Ephesians 5:18-20, Colossians 3:16).

The lifeless keliy are obsolete in the new covenant, done away with by the accomplishment of Christ. The instruments (hoplon) we now present to God for his service are our living bodies. How privileged we are! Every member of the body of Christ may now serve in this priestly function, once reserved for the Levitical tribe of Israel. Gone are the burdensome mechanical furnishings and helps needed under the old dispensation. It is in spirit and truth, with our bodily members, that we now serve and worship God.

To return to the use of the old covenant keliy is to go backward to a more difficult dispensation. How the Levites who labored under the awful realities of the sacrificial system (which included the playing of the musical keliy) would have rejoiced to see our freedom from the external demands of the ceremonial law, a benefit won by Christ, bestowed upon his New Testament church, and enjoyed by her when she worships God in spirit and in truth!